Can a not-quite-reading five year-old benefit from literary discussion groups? I think so, but perhaps not in the way you might have expected. Five year-old No,. 2 and I went to a book discussion of "The Island of Dr. Moreau" this week. This is one of our homeschooling sorts of things that tends to raise eyebrows, and cause confusion among other adults. I imagine, although few of them ask, that said adults wonder what 2 is getting out of such occasions, especially since he's not reading yet. It is true, 2 hadn't read the book, but to be fair neither had I. 7 y.o. No. 1 and and I read through a graphic novel of the book the day of, and hit the highlights with 2. Not being 2, I can't say for sure what he gets out of going to these events, but I can outline what I hope he'll get, what he's told me he wants, and what I've observed. Here we go. Getting the same perks 2 has seen No. 1, (who reads copiously and among many other things wants to